President Barack Obama delivers a speech at Safaricom Indoor
Arena, Sunday, July 26, 2015, in Nairobi. On the final day of his visit
in Kenya, Obama laid out his vision for Kenya’s future, and broad themes
of U.S.-Kenya relations. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)
THE WHITE HOUSE
Office of the Press Secretary
July 26, 2015
REMARKS BY PRESIDENT OBAMA TO THE KENYAN PEOPLE
Safaricom Indoor Arena
Nairobi, Kenya
12:00 P.M. EAT
PRESIDENT OBAMA: Hey!
AUDIENCE: Hey!
PRESIDENT OBAMA: Habari Zenu! (Applause.) Wakenya mpo?
(Applause.) It is great to be back in Kenya. Thank you so much for
this extraordinary welcome. I know it took a few years, but as
President I try to keep my promises, and I said I was going to come, and
I’m here. (Applause.)
Everybody, go ahead and have a seat. I’m going to be talking for a while. (Laughter.) Relax.
I want to thank my sister, Auma, for a wonderful introduction. I’m
so glad that she could be with us here today. And it was — as she said,
it was Auma who first guided me through Kenya almost 30 years ago.
To President Kenyatta, I want to thank you once again for the
hospitality that you’ve shown to me — (applause) — and for our work
together on this visit, and for being here today. It’s a great honor.
I am proud to be the first American President to come to Kenya —
(applause) — and, of course, I’m the first Kenyan-American to be
President of the United States. (Laughter and applause.) That goes
without saying.
AUDIENCE MEMBER: I love you, Obama!
PRESIDENT OBAMA: I love you back. (Applause.) I do.
But, as Auma was saying, the first time I came to Kenya, things were a
little different. When I arrived at Kenyatta Airport, the airline lost
my bags. (Laughter.) That doesn’t happen on Air Force One.
(Laughter.) They always have my luggage on Air Force One. (Laughter.)
As she said, Auma picked me up in an old Volkswagon Beetle, and think
the entire stay I was here it broke down four or five times.
(Laughter.) We’d be on the highway, we’d have to call the juakali —
he’d bring us tools. We’d be sitting there, waiting. And I slept on a
cot in her apartment. Instead of eating at fancy banquets with the
President, we were drinking tea and eating Ugali — (laughter) — and
Sukumawiki.
So there wasn’t a lot of luxury. Sometimes the lights would go out.
They still do — is that what someone said? (Laughter.) But there was
something more important than luxury on that first trip, and that was a
sense of being recognized, being seen. I was a young man and I was just
a few years out of University. I had worked as a community organizer
in low-income neighborhoods in Chicago. I was about to go to law
school. And when I came here, in many ways I was a Westerner, I was an
American, unfamiliar with my father and his birthplace, really
disconnected from half of my heritage. And at that airport, as I was
trying to find my luggage, there was a woman there who worked for the
airlines, and she was helping fill out the forms, and she saw my name
and she looked up and she asked if I was related to my father, who she
had known. And that was the first time that my name meant something.
(Applause.) And that was recognized.
And over the course of several weeks, I’d meet my brothers and aunts
and uncles. I traveled to Alego, the village where my family was from. I
saw the graves of my father and my grandfather. And I learned things
about their lives that I could have never learned through books. And in
many ways, their lives offered snapshots of Kenya’s history, but they
also told us something about the future.
My grandfather, for example, he was a cook for the British. And as I
went through some of his belongings when I went up-country, I found the
passbook he had had to carry as a domestic servant. It listed his age
and his height, his tribe, listed the number of teeth he had missing.
(Laughter.) And he was referred to as a boy, even though he was a grown
man, in that passbook.
And he was in the King’s African Rifles during the Second World War,
and was taken to the far reaches of the British Empire — all the way to
Burma. And back home after the war, he was eventually detained for a
time because he was linked to a group that opposed British rule. And
eventually he was released. He forged a home for himself and his
family. He earned the respect of his village, lived a life of dignity —
although he had a well-earned reputation for being so strict that
everybody was scared of him and he became estranged from part of his
family.
So that was his story. And then my father came of age as Kenyans
were pursuing independence, and he was proud to be a part of that
liberation generation. And next to my grandfather’s papers, I found
letters that he had written to 30 American universities asking for a
chance to pursue his dream and get a scholarship. And ultimately, one
university gave him that chance — the University in Hawaii. And he
would go on to get an education and then return home.
And here, at first he found success as an economist and worked with
the government. But ultimately, he found disappointment — in part
because he couldn’t reconcile the ideas that he had for his young
country with the hard realities that had confronted him.
And I think sometimes about what these stories tell us, what the
history and the past tell us about the future. They show the enormous
barriers to progress that so many Kenyans faced just one or two
generations ago. This is a young country. We were talking last night
at dinner — the President’s father was the first President. We’re only a
generation removed. And the daily limitations — and sometimes
humiliations — of colonialism — that’s recent history. The corruption
and cronyism and tribalism that sometimes confront young nations —
that’s recent history.
But what these stories also tell us is an arch of progress — from
foreign rule to independence; from isolation to education, and
engagement with a wider world. It speaks of incredible progress. So we
have to know the history of Kenya, just as we Americans have to know
our American history. All people have to understand where they come
from. But we also have to remember why these lessons are important.
We know a history so that we can learn from it. We learn our history
because we understand the sacrifices that were made before, so that
when we make sacrifices we understand we’re doing it on behalf of future
generations.
There’s a proverb that says, “We have not inherited this land from
our forebears, we have borrowed it from our children.” In other words,
we study the past so it can guide us into the future, and inspire us to
do better.
And when it comes to the people of Kenya — particularly the youth — I
believe there is no limit to what you can achieve. A young, ambitious
Kenyan today should not have to do what my grandfather did, and serve a
foreign master. You don’t need to do what my father did, and leave your
home in order to get a good education and access to opportunity.
Because of Kenya’s progress, because of your potential, you can build
your future right here, right now. (Applause.)
Now, like any country, Kenya is far from perfect, but it has come so
far in just my lifetime. After a bitter struggle, Kenyans claimed their
independence just a few years after I was born. And after decades of
one party-rule, Kenya embraced a multi-party system in the 1990s, just
as I was beginning my own political career in the United States.
Tragically, just under a decade ago, Kenya was nearly torn apart by
violence at the same time that I was running for my first campaign for
President. And I remember hearing the reports of thousands of innocent
people being killed or driven from their homes. And from a distance, it
seemed like the Kenya that I knew — a Kenya that was able to reach
beyond ethnic and tribal lines — that it might split apart across those
lines of tribe and ethnicity.
But look what happened. The people of Kenya chose not to be defined
by the hatreds of the past — you chose a better history. (Applause.)
The voices of ordinary people, and political leaders and civil society
did not eliminate all these divisions, but you addressed the divisions
and differences peacefully. And a new constitution was put in place,
declaring that “every person has inherent dignity — and the right to
have that dignity respected and protected.” A competitive election went
forward — not without problems, but without the violence that so many
had feared. In other words, Kenyans chose to stay together. You chose
the path of Harambee. (Applause.)
And in part because of this political stability, Kenya’s economy is
also emerging — and the entrepreneurial spirit that people rely on to
survive in the streets of Kibera can now be seen in new businesses
across the country. (Applause.) From the city square to the smallest
villages, MPesa is changing the way people use money. New investment is
making Kenya a hub for regional trade. When I came here as a U.S.
senator, I pointed out that South Korea’s economy was the same as
Kenya’s when I was born, and then was 40 times larger than Kenya’s.
Think about that. It started at the same place — South Korea had gone
here, and Kenya was here. But today, that gap has been cut in half just
in the last decade. (Applause.) Which means Kenya is making progress.
And meanwhile, Kenya continues to carve out a distinct place in the
community of nations: As a source of peacekeepers for places torn apart
by conflict, a host for refugees driven from their homes. A leader for
conservation, following the footprints of Wangari Maathai. (Applause.)
Kenya is one of the places on this continent that truly observes
freedom of the press, and their fearless journalists and courageous
civil society members. And in the United States, we see the legacy of
Kip Keino every time a Kenyan wins one of our marathons. (Applause.)
And maybe the First Lady of Kenya is going to win one soon. (Laughter
and applause.) I told the President he has to start running with his
wife. (Laughter.) We want him to stay fit. (Laughter.)
So there’s much to be proud of — much progress to lift up. It’s a
good-news story. But we also know the progress is not complete. There
are still problems that shadow ordinary Kenyans every day — challenges
that can deny you your livelihood, and sometimes deny you lives.
As in America — and so many countries around the globe — economic
growth has not always been broadly shared. Sometimes people at the top
do very well, but ordinary people still struggle. Today, a young child
in Nyanza Province is four times more likely to die than a child in
Central Province — even though they are equal in dignity and the eyes of
God. That’s a gap that has to be closed. (Applause.) A girl in Rift
Valley is far less likely to attend secondary school than a girl in
Nairobi. That’s a gap that has to be closed. (Applause.) Across the
country, one study shows corruption costs Kenyans 250,000 jobs every
year — because every shilling that’s paid as a bribe could be put into
the pocket of somebody who’s actually doing an honest day’s work.
(Applause.)
And despite the hard-earned political progress that I spoke of, those
political gains still have to be protected. New laws and restrictions
could close off the space where civil society gives individual citizens a
voice and holds leaders accountable. Old tribal divisions and ethnic
divisions can still be stirred up. I want to be very clear here — a
politics that’s based solely on tribe and ethnicity is a politics that’s
doomed to tear a country apart. (Applause.) It is a failure — a
failure of imagination.
Of course, here, in Kenya, we also know the specter of terrorism has
touched far too many lives. And we remember the Americans and Kenyans
who died side by side in the attack on our embassy in the ‘90s. We
remember the innocent Kenyans who were taken from us at Westgate Mall.
We weep for the nearly 150 people slaughtered at Garissa — including so
many students who had such a bright future before them. We honor the
memory of so many other innocent Kenyans whose lives have been lost in
this struggle.
So Kenya is at a crossroads — a moment filled with peril, but also
enormous promise. And with the rest of my time here today, I’d like to
talk about how you can seize the moment, how you can make sure we leave
behind a world that’s better — a world that we borrowed from our
children.
When I first came to sub-Saharan Africa as President, I made clear my
strong belief that the future of Africa is up to Africans. (Applause.)
For too long, I think that many looked to the outside for salvation
and focused on somebody else being at fault for the problems of the
continent. And as my sister said, ultimately we are each responsible
for our own destiny. And I’m here as President of a country that sees
Kenya as an important partner. (Applause.) I’m here as a friend who
wants Kenya to succeed.
And the pillars of that success are clear: Strong democratic
governance; development that provides opportunity for all people and not
just some; a sense of national identity that rejects conflict for a
future of peace and reconciliation.
And today, we can see that future for Kenya on the horizon. But tough
choices are going to have to be made in order to arrive at that
destination. In the United States, I always say that what makes America
exceptional is not the fact that we’re perfect, it’s the fact that we
struggle to improve. We’re self-critical. We work to live up to our
highest values and ideals, knowing that we’re not always going to
achieve them perfectly, but we keep on trying to perfect our union.
And what’s true for America is also true for Kenya. You can’t be
complacent and accept the world just as it is. You have to imagine what
the world might be and then push and work toward that future. Progress
requires that you honestly confront the dark corners of our own past;
extend rights and opportunities to more of your citizens; see the
differences and diversity of this country as a strength, just as we in
America try to see the diversity of our country as a strength and not a
weakness. So you can choose the path to progress, but it requires
making some important choices.
First and foremost, it means continuing down the path of a strong,
more inclusive, more accountable and transparent democracy. (Applause.)
Democracy begins with a peacefully-elected government. It begins
with elections. But it doesn’t stop with elections. (Applause.) So
your constitution offers a road map to governance that’s more responsive
to the people — through protections against unchecked power, more power
in the hands of local communities. For this system to succeed, there
also has to be space for citizens to exercise their rights.
And we saw the strength of Kenya’s civil society in the last
election, when groups collected reports of incitement so that violence
could be stopped before it spun out of control. And the ability of
citizens to organize and advocate for change — that’s the oxygen upon
which democracy depends.
Democracy is sometimes messy, and for leaders,
sometimes it’s frustrating. Democracy means that somebody is always
complaining about something. (Laughter.) Nobody is ever happy in a
democracy about their government. If you make one person happy,
somebody else is unhappy. Then sometimes somebody who you made happy,
later on, now they’re not happy. (Laughter.) They say, what have you
done for me lately? (Laughter.) But that’s the nature of democracy.
That’s why it works, is because it’s constantly challenging leaders to
up their game and to do better.
And such civic participation and freedom is also essential for
rooting out the cancer of corruption. Now, I want to be clear.
Corruption is not unique to Kenya. (Laughter.) I mean, I want
everybody to understand that there’s no country that’s completely free
of corruption. Certainly here in the African continent there are many
countries that deal with this problem. And I want to assure you I speak
about it wherever I go, not just here in Kenya. So I don’t want
everybody to get too sensitive. (Laughter.)
But the fact is, too often, here in Kenya — as is true in other
places — corruption is tolerated because that’s how things have always
been done. People just think that that is sort of the normal state of
affairs. And there was a time in the United States where that was true,
too. My hometown of Chicago was infamous for Al Capone and the Mob and
organized crime corrupting law enforcement. But what happened was that
over time people got fed up, and leaders stood up and they said, we’re
not going to play that game anymore. (Applause.) And you changed a
culture and you changed habits.
Here in Kenya, it’s time to change habits, and decisively break that
cycle. Because corruption holds back every aspect of economic and civil
life. It’s an anchor that weighs you down and prevents you from
achieving what you could. If you need to pay a bribe and hire
somebody’s brother — who’s not very good and doesn’t come to work — in
order to start a business, well, that’s going to create less jobs for
everybody. If electricity is going to one neighborhood because they’re
well-connected, and not another neighborhood, that’s going to limit
development of the country as a whole. (Applause.) If someone in
public office is taking a cut that they don’t deserve, that’s taking
away from those who are paying their fair share.
So this is not just about changing one law — although it’s important
to have laws on the books that are actually being enforced. It’s
important that not only low-level corruption is punished, but folks at
the top, if they are taking from the people, that has to be addressed as
well. (Applause.) But it’s not something that is just fixed by laws,
or that any one person can fix. It requires a commitment by the entire
nation — leaders and citizens — to change habits and to change culture.
(Applause.)
Tough laws need to be on the books. And the good news is, your
government is taking some important steps in the right direction.
People who break the law and violate the public trust need to be
prosecuted. NGOs have to be allowed to operate who shine a spotlight on
what needs to change. And ordinary people have to stand up and say,
enough is enough. (Applause.) It’s time for a better future.
And as you take these steps, I promise that America will continue to
be your partner in supporting investments in strong, democratic
institutions. (Applause.)
Now, we’re also going to work with you to pursue the second pillar of
progress, and that is development that extends economic opportunity and
dignity for all of Kenya’s people.
America partners with Kenya in areas where you’re making enormous
progress, and we focus on what Kenyans can do for themselves and
building capacity; on entrepreneurship, where Kenya is becoming an
engine for innovation; on access to power, where Kenya is developing
clean energy that can reach more people; on the important issue of
climate change, where Kenya’s recent goal to reduce its emissions has
put it in the position of being a leader on the continent; on food
security, where Kenyan crops are producing more to meet the demands of
your people and a global market; and on health, where Kenya has struck
huge blows against HIV/AIDS and other diseases, while building up the
capacity to provide better care in your communities.
America is also partnering with you on an issue that’s fundamental to
Kenya’s future: We are investing in youth. (Applause.) We are
investing in the young people of Kenya and the young people of this
continent. Robert F. Kennedy once said, “It is a revolutionary world
that we live in,” and “it is the young people who must take the lead.”
(Applause.) It’s the young people who must take the lead.
So through our Young African Leaders Initiative — (applause) — we are
empowering and connecting young people from across the continent who
are filled with energy and optimism and idealism, and are going to take
Africa to new heights. (Applause.) And these young people, they’re not
weighted down by the old ways. They’re creating a new path. And these
are the elements for success in this 21st century.
To continue down this path of progress, it will be vital for Kenya to
recognize that no country can achieve its full potential unless it
draws on the talents of all its people — and that must include the half
of Kenyans — maybe a little more than half –who are women and girls.
(Applause.) Now, I’m going to spend a little time on this just for a
second. Every country and every culture has traditions that are unique
and help make that country what it is. But just because something is a
part of your past doesn’t make it right. It doesn’t mean that it
defines your future.
Look at us in the United States. Recently, we’ve been having a
debate about the Confederate flag. Some of you may be familiar with
this. This was a symbol for those states who fought against the Union
to preserve slavery. Now, as a historical artifact, it’s important.
But some have argued that it’s just a symbol of heritage that should fly
in public spaces. The fact is it was a flag that flew over an army that
fought to maintain a system of slavery and racial subjugation. So we
should understand our history, but we should also recognize that it
sends a bad message to those who were liberated from slavery and
oppression.
And in part because of an unspeakable tragedy that took place
recently, where a young man who was a fan of the Confederate flag and
racial superiority shot helpless people in a church, more and more
Americans of all races are realizing now that that flag should come
down. (Applause.) Just because something is a tradition doesn’t make
it right.
Well, so around the world, there is a tradition of repressing women
and treating them differently, and not giving them the same
opportunities, and husbands beating their wives, and children not being
sent to school. Those are traditions. Treating women and girls as
second-class citizens, those are bad traditions. They need to change.
(Applause.) They’re holding you back.
Treating women as second-class citizens is a bad tradition. It holds
you back. (Applause.) There’s no excuse for sexual assault or domestic
violence. There’s no reason that young girls should suffer genital
mutilation. There’s no place in civilized society for the early or
forced marriage of children. These traditions may date back centuries;
they have no place in the 21st century. (Applause.)
These are issues of right and wrong — in any culture. But they’re
also issues of success and failure. Any nation that fails to educate
its girls or employ its women and allowing them to maximize their
potential is doomed to fall behind in a global economy. (Applause.)
You know, we’re in a sports center. Imagine if you have a team and
you don’t let half of the team play. (Laughter.) That’s stupid.
(Laughter and applause.) That makes no sense. And the evidence shows
that communities that give their daughters the same opportunities as
their sons, they are more peaceful, they are more prosperous, they
develop faster, they are more likely to succeed. (Applause.) That’s
true in America. That’s true here in Kenya. It doesn’t matter.
And that’s why one of the most successful development policies you
can pursue is giving girls and education, and removing the obstacles
that stand between them and their dreams. And by the way, if you educate
girls — they grow up to be moms — and they, because they’re educated,
are more likely to produce educated children. (Applause.) So Kenya
will not succeed if it treats women and girls as second-class citizens.
I want to be very clear about that. (Applause.)
Now, this leads me to the third pillar of progress, and that’s choosing a future of peace and reconciliation.
There are real threats out there. President Kenyatta and I spent a
lot of time discussing the serious threat from al-Shabaab that Kenya
faces. The United States faces similar threats of terrorism. We are
grateful for the sacrifices made by Kenyans on the front lines as part
of AMISOM. (Applause.) We’re proud of the efforts that we’re making to
strengthen Kenya’s capabilities through our new Security Governance
Initiative. We’re going to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with you in this
fight against terrorism for as long as it takes. (Applause.)
But, as I mentioned yesterday, it is important to remember that
violent extremists want us to turn against one another. That’s what
terrorists typically try to exploit. They know that they are a small
minority; they know that they can’t win conventionally. So what they
try to do is target societies where they can exploit divisions. That’s
what happens in Iraq. That’s what happens around the world. That’s
what happened in Northern Ireland. Terrorists who try to sow chaos,
they must be met with force and they must also be met, though, with a
forceful commitment to uphold the rule of law, and respect for human
rights, and to treat everybody who’s peaceful and law-abiding fairly and
equally. (Applause.)
Extremists who prey on distrust must be defeated by communities who
stand together and stand for something different. And the most important
example here is, is that the United States and Kenya both have Muslim
minorities, but those minorities make enormous contributions to our
countries. These are our brothers, they are our sisters. (Applause.)
And so in both our countries, we have to reject calls that allow us to
be divided.
This is true for any diverse society. And Kenya is rich with
diversity — with many dozens of tribes and ethnicities, and languages
and religious groups. And time and again, just as we’ve seen the
dangers of religious or ethnic violence, we’ve seen that Kenya is
stronger when Kenyans stand united — with a sense of national identity.
That was the case on December 12, 1963, when cities and villages across
this country celebrated the birth of a nation. It was true in 2010,
when Kenya replaced the anarchy of ethnic violence with the order of a
new constitution. (Applause.)
So we can all appreciate our own identities, our bloodlines, our
beliefs, our backgrounds — that tapestry is what makes us who we are.
But the history of Africa — which is both the cradle of human progress
and a crucible of conflict — shows us that when define ourselves
narrowly, in opposition to somebody just because they’re of a different
tribe, or race, or religion — and we ignore who is a good person or a
bad person, are they working hard or not, are they honest or not, are
they peaceful or violent — when we start making distinctions solely
based on status and not what people do, then we’re taking the wrong path
and we inevitably suffer in the end. (Applause.)
This is why Martin Luther King called on people to be judged not by
the color of their skin but the content of their character. (Applause.)
And in the same way, people should not be judged by their last name,
or their religious faith, but by their content of their character and
how they behave. Are they good citizens? Are they good people?
In the United States, we embrace the motto: E Pluribus Unum. In
Latin, that means, out of many, one. In Kenya, Harambee — we are in
this together. Whatever the challenge, you will be stronger if you face
it not as Christians or Muslims, Masai, Kikuyu, Luo, any other tribe —
but as Kenyans. And ultimately, that unity is the source of strength
that will empower you to seize this moment of promise. That’s what will
help you root out corruption. (Applause.) That’s what will strengthen
democratic institutions. That’s what will help you combat inequality.
That’s what will help you extend opportunity, and educate youth, and
face down threats, and embrace reconciliation.
So I want to say particularly to the young people here today, Kenya
is on the move. Africa is on the move. You are poised to play a bigger
role in this world — (applause) — as the shadows of the past are
replaced by the light that you offer an increasingly interconnected
world. And in the light of this new day, we have to learn to see
ourselves in one another. We have to see that we are connected, our
fates are bound together. Because, in the end, we’re all part of one
tribe — the human tribe. (Applause.) And no matter who we are, or
where we come from, or what we look like, or who we love, or what God we
worship, we’re connected. Our fates are bound up with one another.
Kenya holds within it all that diversity. And with diversity,
sometimes comes difficulty. But I look to Kenya’s future filled with
hope. And I’m hopeful because of you, the people of Kenya, especially
the young people.
There are some amazing examples of what’s going on right now with
young people. I’m hopeful because of a young man named Richard Ruto
Todosia. Richard helped build Yes Youth Can — I like the phrase, Yes
Youth Can — (applause.) It became one of the most prominent civil
society organizations in Kenya, with over one million members. And
after the violence of 2007, 2008, Yes Youth Can stood up to incitement,
helped bring opportunity to young people in places that were scarred by
conflict. That’s the kind of young leadership that we need.
(Applause.)
I’m hopeful because of a young woman named Josephine Kulea.
(Applause.) So Josephine founded Samburu Girls Foundation. And she’s
already helped to rescue over 1,000 girls from abuse and forced
marriage, and helped place them in schools. (Applause.) A member of
the Samburu tribe herself, she’s personally planned rescue missions to
help girls as young as 6 years old. And she explains that, “The longer a
girl is in school, everything for her — for her income, for her family,
for this country — everything changes.” She gives me hope.
I’m hopeful because of a young woman named Jamila Abass. So Jamila
founded Mfarm, which is a mobile platform that is already used by over
14,000 people across Kenya. Mfarm makes it easy for farmers to get
information that lets them match their crops with what the market
demands. And studies show that it can help farmers double their sales.
So here’s what Jamila said: “I love Kenya because you feel you are
home anywhere you go.”
Home anywhere you go — that’s the Kenya that welcomed me nearly 30
years ago as a young man. You helped make me feel at home. And
standing here today as President of the United States, when I think
about those young people and all the young people in attendance here,
you still make me feel at home. (Applause.) And I’m confident that
your future is going to be written across this country and across this
continent by young people like you — young men and women who don’t have
to struggle under a colonial power; who don’t have to look overseas to
realize your dreams. Yes, you can realize your dreams right here,
right now. (Applause.)
“We have not inherited this land from our forebears, we have borrowed
it from our children.” So now is the time for us to do the hard work
of living up to that inheritance; of building a Kenya where the inherent
dignity of every person is respected and protected, and there’s no
limit to what a child can achieve.
I am here to tell you that the United States of America will be a partner for you every step of the way. (Applause.)
God bless you. Thank you. Asante sana. (Applause.)
END
12:43 P.M. EAT
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment